How to Make Money in Probably Stolen
Rent rises every week in Probably Stolen, so your first days decide the run. What to sell first, how heat cuts prices and which perks pay back fastest.

On this page (6)
In Probably Stolen, a plain resale earns only 15% on Mark Up (Normal), so profit is made when you buy. Rent rises every Sunday, so you need discounts, one production line and a few side incomes from week one. Keep next Sunday's rent in cash first, since a missed rent can end your run.
- Retail markup on Mark Up
- 15%
- Store price on Mark Up, Credits
- 12,000
- Georgio's loan payback
- 4x
What should you sell first, and what markup do you get?
Sell what you bought below its value. A trade uses the same price both ways, so a full-price buy earns only the markup. The retail markup is what your difficulty adds to a sale, for customers who accept it.
| Difficulty | Retail markup |
|---|---|
| Price Gouge (Cozy) | +20% |
| Mark Up (Normal) | +15% |
| Thin Margins (Hard) | 0% |
| Red Ink (Challenge) | 0% |
On Thin Margins and Red Ink every Credit comes from a discount. These are the cheapest ways to buy:
- Dr. Jackson on his intro visits: this supplier sells at 75% off on Price Gouge and Mark Up. Stock up now: later his +15% markup cancels your +15% on Mark Up.
- A seller with a full counter: ask for Wholesale. Everything goes at 10% to 75% off, paid in full in cash.
- An ordinary seller: from day 8, when haggling opens, try a 10% Demand Discount. At neutral reputation they accept 80% of the time and walk out 12% of the time.
- The Sunday Merchant: he buys at 15% under value on Mark Up. Sell to him only to cover rent.
The display case is the window that picks who walks in each morning. From day 14, 350+ Credits of water there brings the Water Stockpiler. 300+ of household goods brings the Upper Level Servant.
Once rent is safe, add one earner. These pay back fastest in the first weeks:
| Earner | Start cost | Pays | Why it works |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rustwater to High-Quality water | 250 (a purifier) | 100 (a night, approx.) | A 6 L jug of Rustwater goes from 75 to 375 in 3 nights |
| Appraisal Board | 85 (day 8) | 70-140 (a visit) | No stock needed: a perfect estimate on a 100-Credit item pays 35 as a Junior |
| Stolen goods held until clean | 0 | +10-25% (an item) | You keep the heat discount and lose the risk after 2-6 nights |
| Vending Machine | 1,200 | +10% + markup (nightly) | Sells while you sleep and ignores event price drops |
| Georgio's loan | 1/4 or 1/2 of your cash | 4x (by day 69) | The biggest single payout before you buy the store |
Water is the steadiest line for a new shop, and our Probably Stolen water guide has the whole purifier chain. Contraband sells at up to +150% markup, but every sale raises your inspection risk. The recipes that pay most are in our chemistry guide.
What happens if you can't pay rent or the Loan Shark?
Missing rent doesn't end every run. With Rent Grace, the missed rent moves to next week, on top of that week's raised rent.
You own Rent Grace at the start on Price Gouge and Mark Up. On Thin Margins and Red Ink you don't, so a missed rent means eviction and the run ends. Joe Wild's network, the upgrade shop that opens on day 7, sells it again for 100 Credits, doubled each time.
Rent starts at 200 Credits, comes every Sunday from day 7 and rises after each rent day. Buying the store ends rent for good:
| Difficulty | Rent rise a week | Store price | Mortgage |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price Gouge | +2.5% | 12,000 | 2,500 + 8 x 1,233 |
| Mark Up | +5% | 12,000 | 2,000 + 12 x 930 |
| Thin Margins | +10% | 24,000 | 3,000 + 16 x 1,615 |
| Red Ink | +10% | 36,000 | 7,000 + 16 x 2,370 |
The store price holds until day 50, so day 49 is the last Sunday at the base price. After that it rises 50 Credits a day on Mark Up.
The Loan Shark sells the store on a mortgage. He shows up once your cash reaches the down payment. He offers the deal on a rent day when you hold twice that.
His weekly payment replaces rent. Miss one and he takes goods worth it, and with too few goods the run ends.
| Cash by day 49 | 12,000 |
|---|---|
| Cash on day 70 first rent day after the payback | 13,000 |
| Loan Shark mortgage 2,000 down + 12 x 930 | 13,160 |
On Mark Up, skip him. The mortgage bar is highlighted because it is the most expensive way: 13,160 in all, 1,160 more than cash. Its 930 a week is also over three times the week-7 rent of about 268.
How does heat change the price of stolen goods?
Heat is both your discount and your risk. It is the chance in percent that a Security check finds a stolen item. It drops by 18 every night.
| Item value, Credits | Starting heat | Clean after | Your buying discount |
|---|---|---|---|
| 18-49 | 25 | 2 nights | 10% |
| 50-84 | 50 | 3 nights | 15% |
| 85-139 | 75 | 5 nights | 20% |
| 140+ | 100 | 6 nights | 25% |
The discount is locked in when you buy, so the move is to buy hot and sell clean. Take a stolen 60-Credit item at heat 50. You pay 51, wait 3 nights, then sell it clean for 69 on Mark Up.
That's +18, twice the +9 a clean 60-Credit item makes. Items worth 17 Credits or less are never marked stolen at all.
Which perks and upgrades pay back fastest?
Perks that hand you Credits or a machine pay back first. Starting perks unlock after your first run: you get 3 points and 4 slots, and negative perks give points back.
| Perk | Points | What it's worth |
|---|---|---|
| Savings | 1 | +150 Credits on day 1 |
| Vending Machine | 2 | A 1,200-Credit machine from day 1 |
| Working Pipes | 2 | 600 Credits of tap upgrades and unlimited Rustwater |
| Short Sleeper | 1 | Night scavenging costs you no customer |
| Sycophant | 1 | Upper Levels +15 reputation and +10% to their budgets |
| Bad Lease | gives 1 | About 326 Credits more rent by day 49 (Mark Up) |
| Banned from the Commissary | gives 1 | You lose only the Commissary |
Bad Lease to pay for Savings? Skip the pair. The lease costs about 326 by day 49, and the savings give only 150.
Modules only pay inside a machine that already earns. A Performance Module costs 70 and adds 16% speed. On a purifier making about 100 a night, it pays back in roughly 5 nights.

Joe Wild's upgrades that bring customers beat new machines early. Pick by the problem you have:
- Not enough buyers: Buyer Referral, 200 Credits plus 10 a night, adds a buyer and a display-case buyer every day.
- A full display case but few visitors: Showcase Expansion I, 200 Credits, adds one display-case buyer a day.
- Customers can't afford your stock: Store Renovation I, 500 Credits, adds 150 attractiveness. At 300 attractiveness every budget grows 10%.
On Mark Up, 5% of every trade comes back as Wild's Favor, which pays part of each upgrade.
Are the vending machine, lottery and Georgio's loan worth it?
The vending machine and Georgio's loan are worth it. The lottery only has a chance in a Liquid Luck week.
Vending Machine: buy it from Joe Wild for 1,200, not from the landlord. His offer on days 43, 57, 71 and 85 adds 150 to weekly rent for good. That's 1,200 every 8 weeks.
It sells overnight at item value +10% plus your markup, and event price drops don't touch it. So fill it with goods a surplus event made cheap. Electronic Parts raise its attractiveness by 5 each, and Metal Ingots add shelf rows, up to 12.
Lottery: tickets cost 25 and go on sale every Thursday from day 18. At zero Luck a ticket returns about 15 on average, so the lottery loses money. Liquid Luck is the only week worth a try.
Liquid Luck changes that: +75 Luck for 3 days. That's a 75% chance of a second draw, and the game keeps the better one. One reported run turned about 2,000 Credits of tickets into 6,940, a single result, not a rule.
Georgio gives one on day 27 and sells three on day 32. Drink it Thursday morning so it covers the Friday night draw.
Scratchers cost 20, and a pair pays only 10, so they follow the same rule.
Georgio's loan: on day 43 he asks for a quarter or half of your cash. He pays back 4 times that by day 69, or early on a rent day you can't pay.
Lend half. Lending 3,000 of your 6,000 brings 12,000 back. Waiting for his payback means buying on Sunday, day 70, for about 13,000, a small cost next to that.
What should you do in your first days?
Set aside next Sunday's rent before any of these, then go in this order:
Start as Apprentice (550 Credits) or Water Merchant on Mark Up.
Go to New game
Buy everything resellable on Dr. Jackson's first visits at 75% off.
When an Appraisal Board member offers it on day 8, pay 85 Credits to join.
Put your appraisal certificate in the display case so appraisal customers come.
Go to Display case
Start one water purifier once the rent is safe.
Save Georgio's Liquid Luck for a Thursday lottery week.
When Georgio asks on day 43, lend him half your cash.
Buy the store for 12,000 on day 49, or for about 13,000 on day 70 after his payback.
When a step clashes with rent, rent wins. On Thin Margins and Red Ink, a missed Sunday without Rent Grace ends the run.
So bank Sunday's rent first, then make every Credit at the buying end.
New Probably Stolen guides, straight to your inbox
Unsubscribe anytime. See our Privacy Policy.